On 20 April 2024, Taylor Swift fans joined queues outside British record shops for Record Store Day. The attraction was not the album alone. A limited number of copies of The Tortured Poets Department included a facsimile handwritten note presented as coming from Swift's desk. The album was not itself an official Record Store Day exclusive, but the letter gave fans a reason to buy it in person.

Rough Trade in Soho ordered several hundred additional copies in anticipation of demand. More than 270 UK shops took part in the event, which organisers expected to bring independent retailers £9.7 million. At the same time, the album exceeded 300 million Spotify streams in a single day. The queue was therefore not necessary to hear the music; it was for a paper extra and a physical copy unavailable through streaming.

Listening to the same songs required no line. Waiting connected ownership to a place, a release date, and a limited object. In an era of immediate digital access, scarcity had moved from the recorded sound to the insert and the order at the shop door.